Phd Position in Philosophy of Science

6 maanden geleden


Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

Science communication often involves hyped, overly broad claims about research findings. What are the causes, social epistemological risks, and who’s responsible? In this PhD project, you will be researching these questions.

**Your job**:
We are offering a fully funded four-year PhD position to a researcher interested in philosophically and experimentally investigating _scientific hype_, i.e., the phenomenon that occurs when scientists ‘oversell’, exaggerate, or overgeneralise findings (e.g., to untested populations) when communicating their research to other scientists or the public. This phenomenon has important implications for the social epistemology and ethics of science, as it may involve deception, corrode people’s trust in science, and contribute to failures of scientific replicability. However, scientific hype may also have yet unexplored benefits.

As part of the PhD project, you will develop methods to identify scientific hype, focusing specifically on overgeneralisations expressed in the use of _generics_, i.e., unquantified generalizations (e.g., ‘People with OCD benefit from CBT’). Generics suggest that a claim has a universal scope. Yet, studies show that they are often used in science communication when the reported research does not support such broad claims. You will explore to what extent generics are used in science communication across scientific disciplines, when exactly they are instances of unwarranted scientific hype, why they are used in science communication, and what the resulting epistemic and ethical costs and benefits may be.

Relatedly, while generics may communicate universal generalisations, it is unclear whether scientists take them to have a more restricted meaning than laypeople would do, thus potentially raising different epistemic and ethical risks in scientist-to-scientist compared to scientist-to-public communication. You will investigate the semantics of scientific generics and (together with other researchers) conduct psychological experiments to examine cognitive differences in the processing of generics between scientists and laypeople.

Moreover, since scientific evaluation and reward systems aim to promote the ‘relevance’ and ‘generalisability’ of research findings and generics communicate these features, generics use may inadvertently be incentivised by scientific institutions, as scientists can gain competitive advantages from using them over more accurate claims. However, the interplay between psychological and social/institutional factors in driving problematic generics use and scientific hype remains underexplored, leaving it unclear who is responsible for the harm that may result. You will examine the relevant social dynamics (e.g., through simulation and experimental studies) and help develop interventions and a normative framework to counteract problematic cases of scientific overgeneralisations.

**Your qualities**:
Useful interests and/or skills for this position include:

- interest in the social epistemology of science, specifically the epistemic and ethical risks related to science communication and values in science;
- interest in philosophy of language (e.g., research on generics) and the effects of language on scientific cognition, in particular;
- interest in conducting empirical research (including experimental studies) on cognitive biases, scientific language use, and cognitive differences between laypeople and scientists;
- interest in interdisciplinary applied research that is socially and practically relevant (e.g., to improve science communication practices);
- basic statistics skills (e.g., SPSS, R, etc.) are useful to have but can also be acquired during the project.

**Our offer**:
We offer:

- a position for 18 months, in case of good performance and a positive evaluation, the contract will be extended for the remaining period of 30 months (48 months in total);
- a working week of 38 hours and a gross monthly salary between € 2.770;
- and € 3.539;
- in the case of full-time employment (salary scale P under the Collective Labour Agreement for Dutch Universities (CAO NU));
- 8% holiday pay and 8.3% year-end bonus;
- a pension scheme, partially paid parental leave and flexible terms of employment based on the CAO NU.

In addition to the terms of employment laid down in the CAO NU, Utrecht University has a number of schemes and facilities of its own for employees. This includes schemes facilitating professional development, leave schemes and schemes for sports and cultural activities, as well as discounts on software and other IT products. We also offer access to additional employee benefits through our Terms of Employment Options Model. In this way, we encourage our employees to continue to invest in their growth. For more information, please visit Working at Utrecht University.

**About us**:
A better future for everyone. This ambition motivates our scientists in executing their leading research and inspiring te



  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    Are you interested in philosophical questions surrounding how ML and AI models are used across society for social prediction? Check out this PhD position!Are you interested in philosophical questions surrounding how machine learning and AI models are being used across society for social prediction, like facial recognition, recidivism risk, or job screening?...


  • Utrecht Binnenstad, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    Are you interested in philosophical questions surrounding how machine learning and AI models are being used across society for social prediction, like facial recognition, recidivism risk, or job screening? Check out this PhD position! **Your job**: The same machine learning methods that are unprecedently used across large areas of science are also wide...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    Faculteit of dienst: Faculteit Geesteswetenschappen Afdeling: Departement Filosofie en Religiewetenschap Uren per week: 36 tot 40 Uiterlijk reageren op: 4 maart 2024 We are looking to hire three postdocs in political philosophy (or closely related fields) who want to contribute to the Visions of the Future project. Wat ga je doen? The aims to provide a...

  • Phd in Ethics

    6 maanden geleden


    Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    The Ethics Institute of Utrecht University’s department of Philosophy and Religious Studies seeks a researcher for a four-year, full-time PhD project “_Disrupting ageing_: Personhood, meaning, and vulnerability across the lifespan_”, as part of the inter-university Gravitation consortium _Ethics of Socially Disruptive Technology (ESDiT)_. **Your...

  • Phd in Ethics

    6 maanden geleden


    Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    The Ethics Institute of Utrecht University’s department of Philosophy and Religious Studies seeks a researcher for a four-year, full-time PhD project “_Disrupting ageing_: Personhood, meaning, and vulnerability across the lifespan_”, as part of the inter-university Gravitation consortium _Ethics of Socially Disruptive Technology (ESDiT)_. **Wat ga je...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    The Ethics Institute of Utrecht University’s Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies seeks a researcher for a four-year, full-time PhD project “_Reconceptualising Solidarity for Technologically Disrupted Contexts_”, as part of the inter-university Gravitation consortium _Ethics of Socially Disruptive Technology (ESDiT)_. **Your...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    The Ethics Institute of Utrecht University’s Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies seeks a researcher for a four-year, full-time PhD project “_Reconceptualising Solidarity for Technologically Disrupted Contexts_”, as part of the inter-university Gravitation consortium _Ethics of Socially Disruptive Technology (ESDiT)_. **Wat ga je...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    **Your job**: In recent years, there has been a significant surge of interest in networks, which now play a fundamental role in modern science and society. The network-like structures are widely discussed, from cosmology and communication to economics and ecology. Even at the nanoscale, in materials science, they may offer potential theoretical explanations...


  • Utrecht Oost, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    **Your job**: Many of the standard equations in mathematical physics are based on the fundamental assumption that matter is continuous. In this project, we will revisit such equations by dropping this continuum assumption. We will consider spatial networks - random graph-like structures that permeate space - as the basis and attempt to describe commonly used...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    PFAS (per - and polyfluoroalkyl substances) are so-called ‘’forever chemicals’’ that are found everywhere: in our soils, water, food and bodies. PFAS contamination of soils is an increasingly important global issue, and we still lack sustainable methods for PFAS remediate. The PFAS Remediation Living Lab is a contaminated location at the Utrecht...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    The immune system helps plants resist pathogen infections and has been well studied. However, it becomes increasingly clear that enhancing defense comes at a cost, as plants slow down growth even if the infection is successfully combatted. In this project, you will investigate the poorly understood process of how plants control their growth during and after...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    The immune system helps plants resist pathogen infections and has been well studied. However, it becomes increasingly clear that enhancing defense comes at a cost, as plants slow down growth even if the infection is successfully combatted. In this project, you will investigate how plants control their growth during and after an immune response. This research...


  • Utrecht Oost, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    **Your job**: In single case experimental designs (SCEDs), as applied in therapy effect evaluation, 10-15 measurements of 2-4 outcome variables are typically taken over time. Despite the relative small amount of data, a powerful evaluation can be obtained if (i) the therapy effect on all the outcome variables is evaluated simultaneously, and (ii) the...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    Faculteit of dienst: Faculteit Geesteswetenschappen Afdeling: Departement Filosofie en Religiewetenschap Uren per week: 36 tot 40 Uiterlijk reageren op: 1 maart 2024 We are looking for a new colleague specialising in social and/or political philosophy. The position is open to candidates with various specialisations, both in terms of research themes and in...


  • Utrecht, Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    About the OpportunityAs a PhD candidate at Universiteit Utrecht, you will contribute to groundbreaking research in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and help develop more fair and robust models. The DataDivers project, funded by an ERC Starting grant, aims to improve data quality and collection methods for NLP.Your RoleYou will work closely with the project...


  • Utrecht Oost, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    Join us and help make AI-supported technologies in education more transparent and controllable. **Your job**: Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly embedded in educational technologies to support and enhance learning and teaching. Examples include adaptive learning trajectories, automating feedback, and detecting students with additional needs....


  • Utrecht, Utrecht, Nederland Sticky Voltijd

    At Sticky, we are seeking a PhD candidate to join our team and contribute to the development of AI-assisted systematic reviewing tools. This is an exciting opportunity for a researcher with a passion for understanding human bias in AI-driven processes.About the ProjectThe project 'Transparent and Reproducible AI-aided Systematic Reviewing for the Social...


  • Utrecht, Nederland UMC Utrecht Voltijd

    Dit ga je doen The integration of medical artificial intelligence (AI) in clinical care is paired with pressing ethical questions about its roles and responsibilities. Collaboration between physicians and medical AI systems is frequently promoted in the academic literature as the best way forward to achieve the expected benefits of medical AI. Yet,...


  • Utrecht, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    **Your job**: Cell polarity - the asymmetric distribution of components and functions within a cell along a directional axis - is a fundamental property of cells that is present across the kingdoms of life. Most cells need to distribute proteins, organelles, and functions along an axis of polarity in order to carry out their specialised functions and...


  • Utrecht Binnenstad, Nederland Universiteit Utrecht Voltijd

    PhD position within ERC-funded project RESPIRE to study intersectional power dynamics and socio-environmental in/justice through planetary breathing and suffocation. **Your job**: The PhD position is a part of a research project RESPIRE: Planetary Breathing in Asphyxiating Times lead by Dr. Magdalena Górska and funded by the European Research Council. Your...